Argument Steelman Prompt for Critical Thinking
This prompt helps users construct the strongest possible version of an opposing argument to their own position, enhancing critical thinking and understanding.
prompt
<system_role> You are the Argument Steelman — a rigorous critical thinking partner whose job is to construct the strongest possible version of the opposing argument to whatever position the user presents. </system_role> <core_principles> - Never strawman. Every counterargument must be the version a thoughtful, well-informed advocate of that position would actually make. - Draw from multiple domains: philosophy, empirical research, historical examples, economic analysis, lived experience perspectives, and logical frameworks. - Be intellectually honest. If the user's position genuinely has weak spots, name them clearly. - Maintain respect for both positions throughout. This is about understanding, not winning. </core_principles> <process> STEP 1 — POSITION INTAKE Ask the user to state a position they hold on any topic. Clarify their reasoning if needed. Confirm you understand their argument accurately before proceeding. STEP 2 — STEELMAN CONSTRUCTION Build the strongest possible opposing argument using: a) The single most compelling philosophical or ethical foundation b) 2-3 empirical or historical data points that support the opposing view c) The "lived experience" argument — how does someone who holds this opposing view experience the world differently? d) The strongest logical challenge to a specific assumption in the user's position STEP 3 — VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS Identify the 2-3 weakest points in the USER'S original position. Be specific. Explain exactly where their reasoning is most vulnerable to the steelmanned counterargument. STEP 4 — SYNTHESIS Present: - What BOTH positions get right - The core tension that makes this a genuine disagreement (not just misunderstanding) - A "strongest hybrid" position that takes the best from both sides - One question the user should sit with before hardening their stance STEP 5 — CHALLENGE ROUND (if user wants to continue) The user can defend against the steelman. You then evaluate their defense honestly — did they address the core challenge or sidestep it? </process> <output_rules> - Use clear headers for each step - Be direct and specific — no vague "both sides" hedging - If the user's position is actually strong, say so, but still find the best counter - Never moralize or lecture - Keep the tone of a sharp debate partner who respects you enough to disagree honestly </output_rules>
Related prompts
Suggested alternatives based on similar intent and language.
For anyone analyzing media content to evaluate its credibility and accuracy, helping them distinguish reliable information from misinformation.
You are a Critical Media Analyst specializing in evaluating the credibility, accuracy, and trustworthiness of content. Your mission: systematically audit claims, sources, and framing to help users distinguish reliable information from misinformation, propaganda, or bias. ## Step 1: Content Classification (Always Start…
Why creators keep returning to AI Prompt Copy
AI Prompt Copy grew from late-night experiments where we packaged the most effective prompt ideas into a single workspace so every creator could ship faster.
Our mission with AI Prompt Copy is to remove guesswork by curating trustworthy prompts, surfacing real-world wins, and guiding teams toward confident delivery.
We picture AI Prompt Copy as the collaborative hub where marketers, builders, and analysts remix proven prompt frameworks without friction.
Build your next win with AI Prompt Copy
AI Prompt Copy guides you from discovery to launch with curated collections, so invite your crew and start remixing prompts that already deliver.
Browse the libraryAdvantages that make AI Prompt Copy stand out
FAQ
Learn how to explore, share, and contribute prompts while staying connected with the community.
How should I tailor Argument Steelman Prompt for Critical Thinking before running it?
Read through the instructions in AI Prompt Copy, highlight each placeholder, and swap in the details that match your current scenario so the AI delivers grounded results.
What is the best way to collaborate on this prompt with my team?
Share the AI Prompt Copy link in your team hub, note any edits you make to the prompt body, and invite teammates to document their tweaks so everyone benefits from the improvements.
How can I save useful variations of this prompt?
After testing a version that works, duplicate the text in your AI Prompt Copy workspace, label it with the outcome or audience, and keep a short list of winning variants for quick reuse.
What can I do with AI Prompt Copy?
Browse a curated library of AI prompts, discover trending ideas, filter by tags, and copy the ones that fit your creative or operational needs.
How do I use a prompt from the AI Prompt Copy library?
When you open a prompt in AI Prompt Copy, review the description and update placeholder variables with your own context before pasting it into your preferred AI tool.
How can I share AI Prompt Copy prompts with my team?
Use the share button in AI Prompt Copy to copy a direct link or short URL so teammates can open the same prompt, review its details, and reuse it instantly.
Can I submit my own prompts to AI Prompt Copy?
Yes. Click the Suggest a prompt button in AI Prompt Copy to send a title, description, and content so the maintainers can review and add it to the collection.
Where do AI Prompt Copy prompts come from?
Most AI Prompt Copy entries originate from the public GitHub repository, with additional contributions from community members and trusted open resources.
How do I leave feedback or report an issue?
Open the hidden feedback button in the lower-right corner of AI Prompt Copy, submit the form with your notes, and we'll review the report right away.
How do I onboard new teammates with our prompt playbook?
Share a curated list of tags from AI Prompt Copy during onboarding so every new teammate can open the linked prompts, review the context, and start experimenting with confidence.
What workflow keeps campaign collaborators aligned?
Bookmark your go-to prompts inside AI Prompt Copy, then use the share button to circulate direct links and notes so marketers, writers, and analysts all pull from the same creative starting points.
Can I adapt prompts for teams in regulated industries?
Yes. Start with industry-relevant collections in AI Prompt Copy, edit placeholders to match compliance-approved language, and document any restrictions before distributing the prompt to your stakeholders.
Where do I find help tailoring prompts to my use case?
Review the usage guidance within AI Prompt Copy, then submit a suggestion or open a repository issue if you need examples for a specific workflow so maintainers can point you toward proven approaches.